Most thought leadership isn’t thought, and it isn’t leadership
Updated: Sep 1

It’s a content category. And the buyers it’s aimed at have stopped reading.
I’ve been reading a lot of thought leadership lately. Not for fun. To see what’s out there.
You can spot the AI or plug-and-play template in the first paragraph. A trend statement that no one would disagree with. A statistic from a report nobody cites by name. A three-part "framework" that turns out to be a list. A closing line about “embracing transformation” or “leading with intention” or some other verb-noun combination that means whatever the reader needs it to mean.
We aren't blaming the writing. Most content is produced under conditions that make good thinking nearly impossible: a content calendar that demands two posts a week, a marketing team that doesn’t have access to the experts, an expert who doesn’t have time to be interviewed, and an AI tool filling the gap. The result reads exactly like what it is—something assembled, not written.
And buyers know. Senior buyers—the procurement leads, the CFOs, the clinical directors, the technical evaluators—are pattern-matchers by training. They’ve seen the template too. They scroll past it the way you scroll past a LinkedIn post that opens with “I fired my best employee last week. Here’s why."
This leaves a strange and useful opening.
In a market saturated with assembled content, the firms producing actual thinking are the ones getting read. Not the ones publishing more. The ones publishing less, with more behind it.
Here’s what “with more behind it” actually looks like, in the pieces I’ve seen land with serious buyers:
A real point of view. Not a survey of the field. Not “here are five trends.” A claim the writer is willing to defend, on a question that actually matters to the reader.
Evidence that can be checked. Named sources, traceable data, original interviews. Not a stat floating in a sentence with no provenance.
An argument, not a list. The piece moves from a starting position to a conclusion. The reader can follow the logic and decide whether they agree.
Language that sounds like a person. Not corporate. Not consultant. Not the strange flat dialect that AI tools produce when asked to sound “professional.”
None of this is exotic. It’s just harder than the alternative, and it doesn’t scale the way a content calendar expects. One real piece a quarter beats one assembled piece a week—but only one of those approaches lets a marketing team report “weekly output” in a board meeting.
So the question I’d put to any firm publishing content right now isn’t “How do we make our content better?” It’s a colder one: “Are we publishing because we have something to say, or because the calendar says it’s Tuesday?”
The honest answer to that question is what determines whether the work is worth doing at all.



Comments